Facts or Anecdotes? The battle for the truth over the outcomes of military service
Every time new research speaks to the negative outcomes of military service a number of serving personnel and pro-military veterans – spontaneously or otherwise – take to social media to relate their own positive anecdotal experience. This was again the case with the recent Child Rights International Network report on the army’s targeting of recruitment towards young people from socially deprived backgrounds.
‘The army made a man out of me!’ is one common claim, alongside others like ‘I wouldn’t be where I am today without joining up” and “I’d be dead or in jail if not for the military.’
This last one deserves particular attention today following a report in the press on Sunday suggesting that veterans are the biggest occupational group in UK jails.
Dr Nicholas Murdoch, head of research at military charity Care After Combat, told the Sun newspaper: ‘Veterans are the biggest occupational group in prisons. The convictions are quite broad. Violence is common and we’re seeing more individuals who served in recent conflicts.’
Frances Crook, CEO of the Howard League for Penal Reform, quickly followed up on Twitter, referencing her organisation’s report on veterans in jail. Titled The Report of the Inquiry into Former Armed Service Personnel in Prison, the League’s study found that many ex-military personnel jails were serving time for violent or sexual crimes against women and children.… Read more