The British Legion wants us to ‘Rethink Remembrance’ but they are not the only ones

It may be a surprising message on the face of it, but the Royal British Legion is asking the public to ‘Rethink Remembrance’.

That does not, however, suggest we will see the Legion advocating growth in peace studies, or calling for more debate around how the military operates in public life and beyond.

Instead, via their ‘Rethink Remembrance’ Poppy Appeal, the Legion is asking us to focus not only on the dead and the veterans of two world wars but also those of today’s generation.

In terms of the Legion as a welfare charity, this is uncontroversial. What is more unsettling is how the British Legion seeks to define public remembrance, determining who it is for and how we should engage with it.

Furthermore, the militaristic dimension of remembrance is problematic for many; this has been nurtured by policies and public relations that promote support for the military in the aftermath of the controversial wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.

As a consequence, the level of debate over recent years about ‘poppy politics’ has grown significantly, reaching fever-pitch in some quarters; the nature of public remembrance changed long before we were asked to ‘rethink’ it.… Read more

Tory boost for cadets in schools needs fighting

In the 2015 budget, the Chancellor of the Exchequer announced £50 million of second phase funding from Libor fines, increasing the number of state school cadet units to 500 by 2020. (4)

In 2016 he announced a further half a million from Libor fines, to support seven Cadet ‘linked detachments’ in Scottish schools as well as £3.3m for Cadet Forces qualifications. (5)

While the Government heralds the cadets as a silver bullet in terms of improving pupil attainment and development, the sight of ranks of pupils as young as 12 in military gear and handling weapons will ring alarm bells for many. That this is happening within education raises additional concerns.

Cadet forces in schools are not new of course. Many independent schools have long run Combined Cadet Forces (CCF).

Now, it is the Department for Education (DfE) rather than the Ministry of Defence (MoD) promoting cadets and ‘military ethos’ in schools.

Figures suggest that 69 new units have been set up in state schools, with MoD funding, other bursaries and assistance of a partner CCF in an independent school. (6)

The ‘military ethos’ in schools programme also includes the far-from-successful Troops to Teachers scheme which fast-tracks veterans into teaching, and ‘alternative provision with a military ethos’.… Read more

Scottish Parliament asks for more information on military visits to schools after hearing from ForcesWatch

Back in March we asked Holyrood to ensure ‘guidance is provided to schools’, ‘information is collected to provide public monitoring’ and ‘parents/guardians are consulted’ when it comes to visits by the military. Last week we gave evidence to the Public Petitions Committee.

Things have really moved on since ForcesWatch and Quakers in Scotland lodged a petition earlier this year with the backing of over a thousand signatures at the Scottish Parliament concerning military visits to state schools.

Back in March we asked Holyrood to ensure ‘guidance is provided to schools’, ‘information is collected to provide public monitoring’ and ‘parents/guardians are consulted’ when it comes to visits by the military.

This reflected the work done with the Welsh Assembly in 2015 when Assembly Members in Cardiff agreed to support, in principle, greater oversight, guidance and balance in relation to how the armed forces operate in secondary schools. This decision was made in recognition of the unique nature of an armed forces career.

Last week we got the chance to put our case to the Public Petitions Committee in Edinburgh. We answered questions on how visits to schools is part of the armed forces long-term recruitment process, about the level and distribution of visits, and the lack of clarity and coordination between institutions and authorities responsible for education and careers as to how, and even if, the visits should be overseen and parents consulted.… Read more

Armed Forces Day: ‘It is peace we must strive for, not increasing militarisation’

It was with deep unease that I learnt Camden had raised the Armed Forces Flag earlier this week in support of Armed Forces Day.

The borough, I’m told, is required to hoist the flag because in 2013 it signed the Armed Forces Community Covenant; a mistake in my view.

Armed Forces Day has been described by the Quakers as “a glossy front behind which sits a deliberate strategy to manipulate the public”. Celebrating our armed forces in this way suggests an uncritical acceptance of military approaches to conflict resolution.

The clear aim, led by the defence ministry and the Tory government, is for the UK to become more militarised in an everyday sense; adopting militaristic values and priorities and to see military solutions as particularly effective.

Since 2012 the government has committed over £90million for new programmes in schools with “a military ethos” while slashing Education Maintenance Allowance, Disabled Students Allowance and mental health services for young people.

Military-led activities in national education policy include aggressive plans to spread Army Cadet Forces to state schools (over 500 by 2020); arms companies and the military sponsoring new academies and influencing what they teach, plus military personnel being brought ever more into classrooms.… Read more

Making the link with child development

Are 16 and 17 year olds developmentally mature enough to make rational decisions about enlisting and once they have joined? The Chair of Neurology at the University of Pennsylvania says: 16 years olds “may be more prone to being stressed, to maybe malfunctioning under stress and also not using more rational a decision making approach when they are in that split second.”

As we report elsewhere, this week has seen media coverage and discussions on the age of recruitment to the UK armed forces, sparked by the open letter to the MoD signed by 20 childrens rights organisations. The letter noted how the youngest recruits are ‘actively sought’ for frontline roles and that, “Since the mental health effects of childhood adversity can be aggravated in a military environment, the effects of enlisting too early can be particularly harmful for some young people.”

The BBC and others covered the story in several places including this Radio 5 Live panel discussion (from 2 hours: 41 minutes) which had an interview with Dr Frances Jenson, a brain development specialist and Chair of Neurology at the University of Pennsylvania (author of The Teenage Brain and this TED talk) whose work focuses on the differences between the adult and teenage brain.… Read more

The UN, child rights and the UK military

This week the long-awaited consideration of the UK’s implementation of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child takes place. There are numerous issues being discussed, including many ways in which the rights of children are compromised or not adequately recognised by UK authorities.

Also under scrutiny is the recruitment of 16 and 17 year olds, who are still legally children, into the UK armed forces, and UK’s lack of education provision on peace and human rights. As an open letter to the MoD points out, the youngest recruits are ‘actively sought’ for frontline roles.

June 2016 update: Read the Committee on the Rights of the Child recommendations on the recruitment of under-18s to the UK armed forces and recruitment activities in schools.

These are both issues on which the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child made recommendation the last time they reviewed the UK compliance of the Convention in 2008.

They are also issues on which ForcesWatch and others have made submissions to the UN because the UK is failing to implement the UN’s recommendations and abide by the sprit of the Convention.

Our report on Peace education and the promotion of the armed forces in UK schools highlights not only the lack of provision of peace education for young people but also that there is increased promotion of the military within schools – through the Department for Education’s ‘military ethos’ programme and free military-related learning resources, and as the armed forces continue to conduct a substantial ‘youth engagement’ programme.… Read more

5 Soldiers: The Body is the Frontline.

Lauren Bryden & Poppy Kohner explore the implications of Rosie Kay’s production of 5 Soldiers: The Body Is The Frontline, a dance piece exploring the ‘physicality’ of war and its effect on soldiers’ bodies.

While captivating and enlightening, does placing the body at the centre of the narrative of war obscure political comment on what these bodies do and, crucially, why they do it? The support of the production by the British Army and their presence at the event raises important questions about the role of the military in public arts spaces.

On the evening of Friday 29 April in Tramway 1 – one of the most impressive, and experimental, theatre spaces in Scotland – we found ourselves captivated by Rosie Kay’s production of 5 Soldiers: The Body Is The Frontline; a show that, in Scotland, is supported, part-funded and produced in association with the British Army. 

Kay’s 5 Soldiers is not an anti-war dance piece, nor is it intended to be. Instead, Kay’s focus for the performance is the ‘physicality’ of war, and offers a parallel between dancers’ and soldiers’ bodies, inspired by Kay’s personal experience of long-term injury and the arduous regime demanded of a professional dance career.… Read more

Scottish voices on armed forces visits to schools

Before the closing date of our petition to the Scottish Parliament on military visits to state schools in Scotland, the ForcesWatch team went on the road to spread the word and raise awareness of the issue.

What we discovered, after public meetings in Edinburgh, Glasgow and in Aberdeen in mid-March, was a clear appetite for change. Many in Scotland – teachers, students, parents and others – are uncomfortable with the status quo of armed forces visits to Scottish schools. The country’s largest teaching union – the Educational Institute of Scotland – has opposed military recruitment in schools and colleges since 2007. The Executive of the National Union of Students Scotland decided in 2015 to oppose armed forces recruitment in colleges and universities, a policy due to be ratified by the full conference this month. The Scottish Parents Teacher Council worry that students are encountering a sanitised image of the armed forces, and say parents must always be consulted about the visits.

Overall there is a willingness to see – as our petition states – ‘greater scrutiny, guidance and consultation on armed forces visits’. We heard many testimonies, expert views and opinions. We were joined by members of the public and peace groups, and by military veterans and political activists including members of the Scottish Green Party and the SNP.… Read more

Bringing it up to date: 100 years on from the First World War

ForcesWatch is a research and campaigning organisation which challenges military recruitment practices in the UK that are not in the best interests of young people. They are currently working on raising the age of recruitment to 18, in partnership with Child Soldiers International, and challenging the growing presence of the military in the education system, along with Quakers in Britain.

Emma Sangster from ForcesWatch discusses their work.

It is hard to believe that 100 years after a quarter of a million boy soldiers signed up to fight in the First World War that we are still working to ensure that vulnerable youngsters are not seduced into enlisting. ForcesWatch research has looked at how, from almost every aspect, the best interests of 16 and 17 year old recruits are not served well by this policy, despite the prevalent narrative that the armed forces provide a valuable route out of disadvantage.

The UK is the only country in the EU to still recruit into the armed forces at 16. This is despite being a signatory to the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child and the Optional Protocol on the Involvement of Children in Armed Conflict. However, public opinion is definitely on the side of children’s rights and we believe it is only a matter of time before this anachronistic policy changes.

… Read more

Scotland petition about armed forces in schools is launched amid cadets row

Good news – after months of hard work ForcesWatch and Quakers in Scotland have now formally submitted our petition to the Scottish Parliament calling for an inquiry into armed forces visits to schools. We are urging MSPs to strike a ‘new deal’ on armed forces visits to schools, ensuring greater scrutiny, transparency and guidance over visits.

There’s already been a hugely positive response to the petition, with more than four hundred signatories in the first four days. You too can sign it, whether you live in Scotland or not. You’ll find it here and it’s live until the 20th March.

Please do Tweet and Facebook the link – and tell friends and family. We are also planning a series of local meeting to discuss the issues raised in the petition. These will be held in Edinburgh on Monday 14th March at the Quaker Meeting House, Glasgow on Tues 15th at the STUC, and Aberdeen on Thurs 17th at the Quaker Meeting House – details here.

The Scottish media has been keen to cover the story with The Herald newspaper and prominent website the Common Space running full articles about the petition.

These both quoted ForcesWatch coordinator – Emma Sangster – saying: “A new deal is badly needed on this issue as the number of visits that the armed forces make to schools has risen significantly over the past ten to twelve years.… Read more